Welcome to Pagliai’s Pizza - A Southern Illinois Tradition Since 1968

Discover the authentic taste of tradition at Pagliai’s Pizza, a Carbondale landmark proudly serving Southern Illinois for over 55 years. Located at 509 S Illinois Avenue, our family-owned pizzeria is renowned for its commitment to fresh, high-quality ingredients and time-honored recipes that make us a favorite for Southern Illinois pizza lovers.

Menu Highlights

At Pagliai’s, every meal is a celebration of flavor and craftsmanship. Our menu features:

  • Handmade Dough: Crafted daily from a secret family recipe, ensuring a perfect foundation for our pizzas.

  • Homemade Sausage: Seasoned and blended in-house using our traditional family spice mix.

  • Fresh Ingredients: From sliced mushrooms to cheese cut and ground on-site, every ingredient is prepared with care.

  • Signature Meat Pasta Sauce: Made from scratch and slow-cooked all day for a rich, savory experience.

Tradition

Pagliai’s Pizza is more than just a restaurant; it’s a Southern Illinois tradition. With new owners Jason and Sulla, an SIU alumna, we continue the legacy of excellence set by our founders. Every visit to Pagliai’s promises the same exceptional quality and warm, welcoming atmosphere that our customers have loved for decades.

Events and Catering

Planning an event? Pagliai’s offers versatile spaces for your gatherings:

  • Seats 50+: Equipped for larger events.

  • Seats 40: Perfect for smaller meetings.

Our catering services provide delicious options for inside dining, delivery, or pickup. Please allow 24 hours' notice for catering orders to ensure your event is a success.

Hours of Operation

Join us for lunch or dinner at the following times:

  • Monday - Thursday: 11 am – 9 pm

  • Friday: 11 am – 10 pm

  • Saturday: 11 am – 10 pm

  • Sunday: 4 pm – 9 pm

Contact Us

Visit us at 509 S Illinois Avenue, Carbondale, IL 62901, or call 618-457-0321 to place an order or inquire about our catering services.

Experience Pagliai’s Today

Whether you’re craving a classic pizza or planning a special event, Pagliai’s Pizza is here to provide an unforgettable dining experience. Come and taste why we’ve been a beloved part of the Southern Illinois pizza scene for generations.